Trotskyist historian Jean-Jacques Marie wrote a critical book about Stalin. History and criticism of a black legend (January 2011, Editions Aden, Brussels). This criticism, "The Gulag Socialism!" Has été adressée par un ami de J-J. Marie à la traductrice qui l’a faite suivre à l’auteur. Nous la reproduisons ici avec l’accord des deux mandataires, Jean-Jacques Marie et Michel Barbe, professeur d’histoire agrégé (à la retraite), à Marseille.
La diffusion de la critique et de la réponse de Domenico Losurdo peut contribuer à promouvoir un débat libre et fécond pour ceux qui souhaitent faire un bilan critique de l’histoire du mouvement communiste, et redonner force et actualité au projet communiste de transformation de la société [M.-A. Patrizio, Marseille].
SOCIALISM THE GULAG!
About Stalin, History and criticism of a black legend "by Domenico Losurdo
by Jean-Jacques Marie
A valiant heart nothing is impossible, if we believes the Scouts. Domenico Losurdo male denies this currency. Brave heart he is undoubtedly an attempt to rehabilitate Stalin. But the futility of such a company whose ambition is no doubt exaggerated , jump quickly to the eyes ...
A valiant heart nothing is impossible, if we believes the Scouts. Domenico Losurdo male denies this currency. Brave heart he is undoubtedly an attempt to rehabilitate Stalin. But the futility of such a company whose ambition is no doubt exaggerated , jump quickly to the eyes ...
Answer
The primitive thought and Stalin as a scapegoat
Domenico Losurdo
It can not be enough to appreciate the wisdom of the motto attributed to Georges Clemenceau: War is too serious to be entrusted to the generals! Whilst on his chauvinism and anti-communism, the French Prime Minister kept a very lucid consciousness to the fact that the specialists (in this case the specialists of the war) are often able to see the trees but not the forest, get overwhelmed by the details of losing view of the whole; In this sense, they know everything except what is essential. At that Clemenceau was immediately led to believe when you read the slating that Jean-Jacques Marie would like to reserve my book on Stalin. Apparently, the author is one of the leading experts' Trotskyism-logy, "and is keen to show it in all circumstances ...
French version of M.-A. Patrick
La pensée primitive Stalin et comme bouc Emissive
Vladimir Since March 7, 2011 9:55
Caro Domenico,
questa tua risposta, oltre ad essere del tutto pertinente nel merito, e' una vera e propria lezione di metodo storico.
Vladimir Since March 7, 2011 9:55
Caro Domenico,
questa tua risposta, oltre ad essere del tutto pertinente nel merito, e' una vera e propria lezione di metodo storico.
0 comments:
Post a Comment